TRAVERSING THE BACK DOOR OF THE MIND

DIRECTING IMAGINATIVE STORIES TO GENERATE MEANINGFUL DIALOGUE ABOUT BIBLICAL TRUTHS IN A MATERIALIST WORLD

  • WHAT IS ONTOLOGICAL MATERIALISM AND HOW DOES IT AFFECT PEOPLE'S WORLDVIEW?

    The belief that the ultimate value in life is anchored in the finite and physical materials, thus one fails to grasp the importance of eternity.  

  • WHAT ARE THE REASONS TO AN ONTOLOGICAL MATERIALIST'S HOSTILITY TOWARDS SPIRITUAL TRUTHS?

    The Post-Christian Era and the rejection of overtly “Christian“ materials.

  • HOW CAN MEANINGFUL DIALOGUE ON SPIRITUAL TRUTHS BE GENERATED AMONGST AN AUDIENCE THAT IS HOSTILE TOWARDS EVANGELISTIC MATERIALS THAT ARE LABELED AS "CHRISTIAN"?

    Francis Schaeffer’s pre-evangelism method, which is “taking the roof off” in a loving way, exposing one’s preconceived reality against the reality.

  • HOW CAN STORYTELLING BE USED TO CREATE CONTEXTUAL UNDERSTANDING OF SPIRITUAL TRUTHS AMONGST AN AUDIENCE THAT SUBSCRIBES TO THE CONCEPT OF ONTOLOGICAL MATERIALISM?

    “If you want someone to hear the truth, you should tell them the truth. But if you want someone to love the truth, you should tell them a story.”

    -Andrew Peterson

  • HOW EFFECTIVE IS STORYTELLING IN GENERATING MEANINGFUL DIALOGUE IN EVANGELISM?

    Reason invites one to willingly engage with meaning, while imagination ignites a hunger for clarity.

  • WHAT IS THE PSYCHOLOGICAL IMPACT NARRATIVE PERSUASION HAS ON AN AUDIENCE?

    Transportation and identification together reduce resistance toward persuasive messages found in the narrative by immersing the individual in the story, making it more personal and realistic.

  • WHAT ATTITUDE DO PEOPLE HAVE ON THE IDEA OF ETERNITY SPECIFICALLY FROM A BIBLICAL PERSPECTIVE ABOUT LIFE BEYOND DEATH?

    “I do not believe either way. If there is, it would not affect what I have been working on. If not, I would not need one. It is this finite life that gives us meaning to live.”

    -Survey respondent

WHAT IS ONTOLOGICAL MATERIALISM?

 

THE DEFINITION OF ONTOLOGY

Ontology is “the study of being as being. What is there?” Thus ontology is the study of existence itself; which is closely related to the study of metaphysics, which seeks to answer: What is real? (Cowan and Spiegel 146).

DEFINE MATERIALISM

Materialism is an old ontological category that understands the world as consisting exclusively of material entities (Crane and Mellor 185-206). They hold to the idea that “when you’re dead, you’re dead!” (Crane and Melor 234), therefore it is unnecessary to even presuppose the existence of any substances one cannot “directly experience” through material matters (Crane and Melor 158).

DEFINE ONTOLOGICAL MATERIALISM

For this research, ontological materialism is defined as a belief, a value system and a worldview that a materialistically minded person adhere to in their daily life.


EFFECT ON ONE'S WORLDVIEW

 

DEFINE WORLDVIEW

A worldview is defined as “a comprehensive system of beliefs” that allows individuals to explain and interpret the world around them as they apply this set of related beliefs to their way of living and values (Foreman 66).

G. K. Chesterton, one of the greatest writers of the 20th century, stated that it is more important to get to the core of a person and know “one’s view of the universe” (Chesterton 8) than mere facts about the individual.

THE ONTOLOGICAL MATERIALISTIC WORLDVIEW

A person with an ontological materialist worldview understands that physical phenomena are the only thing that constitute existence (Setzer), and as stated before that materialism is “nothing more than a survival mechanism” (Crane and Mellor 164).

Consequently, one’s definition of success in life can only be measured by one’s accumulated material possessions (Waggoner). People are taught to believe that a good life must be experienced in the here and now and is gained by one’s capability to securing a job and gaining wealth. 

THEISTIC WORLDVIEW

A theistic worldview informs one about the reality of eternity, a life beyond death (John 3:16). Furthermore, death is unavoidable because of sin (Rom. 6.23); however, contrary to the ontological materialistic worldview, this life is only seen as a temporary home.

The eternal life begins after death (2 Pet. 1.13-14). A person who holds a theistic worldview understands that the ultimate fulfilment in life cannot be satisfied with earthly possessions that are destined to pass (Matt. 6.19-20).


METHODS TO REACH THE POST CHRISTIAN ONTOLOGICAL MATERIALIST

 

PRE-EVANGELISM

The good news of the Gospel is unquestionable, and an individual needs to understand how it is vital for his or her life.

Francis Schaeffer, a distinguished evangelical theologian, introduced this concept as pre-evangelism, which is “taking the roof off” in a loving way, exposing one’s preconceived reality against the reality.

It is important to understand that although this approach does not lead an individual directly to the Gospel. It is a ploughing process for the heart to be ready for the Gospel, by revealing the poverty within their preconceived worldviews when it is placed up against reality (Little 39:45-40:38).

 

EXPERIENCING REALITY THROUGH IMAGINATION

Imagination is not a form of propaganda for Christianity that ignores the grim of reality of the world, but instead Coleridge states it is used to awaken and bring attention to the mind “from the lethargy of custom” and to remove “the film of familiarity and selfish solicitude” (Roberts 208).

Imagination offers the individual a renewed view of reality to help one “see things as we are (were) meant to see them” (Ordway 88). Lewis stating that imagination, like “all things, in their way, reflect heavenly truth” (Vainio 6).

UTILIZING IMAGINATIVE STORYTELILING IN PRE-EVANGELISM

Lewis approached pre-evangelism with “narrative theology.” His goal was to lead people to experience truths through symbols and metaphors.

In his essay Transposition, Lewis expressed the difficulty of “translating higher theological realities, those of heaven, into the language of lower realities, our common experiences on earth” (Sheahan 166), stating that the ultimate reality of the Christian faith cannot be fully comprehended solely through the rational faculty, which he illustrates as “a single instrument instead of a whole orchestra” (Sheahan 167).

 

REASON AND IMAGINATION

Reason invites one to willingly engage with meaning, while imagination ignites a hunger for clarity; consequently, an integration of both modes is where “the fullest engagement with truth” is found (Ordway 164).

In his essay Bluspels and Falansferes, Lewis believes that imagination, as the “organ of meaning,” supplies the materials for reason to operate. “Imagination,” he states, “is not the cause of truth, but its condition.” (Lewis 265). Scilicet, the meaning of a word or concept could only be truly understood when a connection is made with a clear image.  


NARRATIVE PERSUASION

 

IDENTIFICATION

Characters who are identified by first person pronouns, such as “self” or “I” and “whose inner consciousness is represented” creates a stronger identification with the individual (Green 100). 

The individual begins to create an affinity with the characters in the story by stepping into the mind of people they are not, the individual begins perceiving the story from the character’s perspective by adopting their belief system, perceived goals and values.

This internalization of the narrative promotes the individual to understand the message as important to their own lives and experiences (Shen 169). 

 

TRANSPORTATION

This idea of immersing oneself in the narrative is known as transportation (Shen 168), where individuals bring in personal experience, real-world backgrounds, and goals, while being “active processors” (Green 101) as they interpret and attempt to make sense of the story. 

Individuals are not only more willing to accept assertions presented by the narrative, but even tend to “utilize them to answer questions about the world” (Dohlstrom 304).


JESUS AS A STORYTELLING

 

Stories are “the Holy Spirit’s literary genre of choice” (Peterson 3). Not only does over half of the Bible contain stories (Steffen 150), 27% of Jesus’ teachings were parables (Dillon 181).

In fact, the book of Matthew indicates that Jesus never spoke to crowds without parables, and that “this was to fulfill what was spoken by the prophet: “I will open my mouth in parables; I will utter what has been hidden since the foundation of the world” (Matt. 13.35).

Jesus’ parables are a “metaphorical comparison” (Sider 455) between everyday life experiences and divine abstract truths about the Kingdom of God.

Jesus Himself began a parable in Luke with, “What is the kingdom of God like? And to what shall I compare it?” (Lk. 13.18). 

This verse clearly shows that parables are not simply told for entertainment but are  purposefully crafted “to teach spiritual truths by way of comparison” (Resendes 18).

The majority of Jesus’ parables are open-ended and filled with questions. Instead of bringing His listeners to a solid conclusion. He challenged His listeners to continue to ponder, to slow down and think about the meaning behind the parables. 

Jesus engaged His listener by “creating an experience in the imagination” (Resendes 44), and then He challenges them to make a decision.

QUALITATIVE PRIMARY RESEARCH

  • 1. What are you spending the majority of your time on? How does investing time into that activity benefit you?

    Respondents stated that they spend the majority of their time on work and gaining more knowledge in order to “benefit my career” and “to upgrade my social status.”

  • 2. What is your attitude towards death? Do you talk about it? Do you fear it?

    Most of the respondents stated that there is a fear towards death that one will be “facing death without fully attaining one’s goals and achievements.” However, it is not a topic that is being brought up in conversations since one is “too busy to live life”.

  • 3. Do you believe that there is something beyond the current life? How does that belief determine your choices?

    Half of respondents did not believe that there is anything beyond the current life, stating that “it’s the finite life that gives us meaning to live,” holding the attitude that it is more important to “live in the moment” and that anything beyond the current life is incomprehensible.

  • 4. No one can determine when their last breath is. If you knew, how would you live your life differently? Would your ultimate value in life still matter, remain the same, or be different?

    All respondent stated that if they knew when their last breath is, their ultimate value in life wound remain the same: “Same values, to experience as much as I can in life.”

  • 5. What is your ultimate value in life? Where do you find the meaning of life?

    Most respondents indicated that it is important to “live your life and to be the master of your life,” that being true to oneself and others and making a positive influence in the world is where one finds ultimate meaning in life.